Why God Doesn’t Remove Our Sinful Cravings Immediately

Posted by Pastor J.D. on March 17, 2015

Every Christian I know has had the experience of coming up against the same sin—again—and wondering, “Will this struggle ever end? Why doesn’t God just remove this?” (If you haven’t had that experience, just give it time.) This seems to be a frustration common to all believers, and not just with sin, either. When we experience any prolonged suffering or pain or discomfort, we have to ask, Why?

This isn’t the question of a skeptic trying to prove that God doesn’t exist—the famous apologetic “problem of evil.” No, this is the personal question of a believer trying to discern what in the world God is doing with the continued struggles in his life. It is the question of someone who reads, “For those who love God, all things work together for good,” and trying to reconcile that theological truth with her present circumstances.

One of the most surprising insights into this question comes from Judges 3. Tucked in between the stories of Othniel and Ehud is a statement that most Christians skip right over. But if we took this truth to heart, we’d have a renewed courage to face our struggles: “Now these are the nations that the LORD left, to test Israel by them, that is, all in Israel who had not experienced all the wars in Canaan. It was in order that the generations of the people of Israel might know war, to teach war to those who had not known it before.” (Judges 3:1-2)

Why did God leave struggles for his people, Israel? Israel’s struggle was tangible and obvious: it came in the form of enemy nations and their armies. So why didn’t God drive them out?

In one sense, as the book of Judges pounds into our heads over and over, the enemy nations are there because Israel didn’t believe God enough to drive them out. But that’s not what Judges 3 says. No, here we see that God left them there to test Israel so that they might learn to fight wars.

God wanted to give Israel the land of Canaan. But apparently, he wanted to do it through struggle. So he continued to test them, to see if they would believe him, to teach them to trust him in their fight. He does the same with us, though (as Paul reminds us) our battle isn’t against flesh and blood, but against spiritual powers. Why doesn’t God remove our struggles when we become Christians? Because he wants us to keep relying on his grace, not on our flesh. As Paul said, some of the weaknesses and trials in our lives are there—by design—to keep us humble.

What this means is that sometimes God allows us to struggle with a lesser sin to keep us from a greater one—pride. Because if you or I were immediately cured from certain sins, we’d become insufferably proud. I know that God has done that with me, specifically in my marriage. The first couple years of my marriage were a struggle for both my wife and me. We had a lot of junk that needed to be exposed. But when I look back, I’m thankful for that time, because it keeps me from becoming self-righteous when I look at problems other people have in their marriages. Struggle is a constant way of driving the proverb, “There, but for the grace of God, go I,” into our hearts.

John Newton, the author of “Amazing Grace,” understood this from experience as well. He grew frustrated by the continued sin in his life, until it dawned on him that any remaining sin kept him in desperate need of grace: “The riches of his mercy,” he said, “are more illustrated by the multiplied pardons he bestows upon me, than if I needed no forgiveness at all.”

The persistence of pain in our lives—especially the pain of battling against sin—shouldn’t make us complacent. God didn’t leave the Canaanites so that Israel would eventually get comfortable with them being around. It was just the opposite: he left the Canaanites so that Israel would learn to fight.

So when you are tempted to despair because you continue to struggle, remember what God is doing through your circumstances. Look to Christ, whose resurrection guarantees victory. Look to Christ, who fought for you when you were his enemy. Look to Christ, the only Savior who can give you the strength to stand, and who will pick you up every time you fall. Look to Christ, and fight.


For more on this, be sure to listen to the entire message here.


Pastor J.D.


J.D. Greear is pastor of The Summit Church, in Raleigh-Durham, NC and author of Gospel: Recovering the Power that Made Christianity Revolutionary (2011) and Stop Asking Jesus into Your Heart: How to Know for Sure You Are Saved (2013). More

17 responses to Why God Doesn’t Remove Our Sinful Cravings Immediately

  1. Needed this today. Thank you.

  2. I believe he uses struggles to keep us humble. I think without those struggles it would be all about us, less about his grace. I have learned to be thankful for all his works that keeps me searching for his great mercies and grace.

  3. Could it be that in eternity God may want us to have a strong understanding of the negative ramifications of sin so that we detest it immensely? How could we truly understand the benefits of being in a holy, (sinless) paradise without some experiences with the battles of sin? I would add these thoughts to your insightful ones.

  4. Thanks JD!

    This is outstanding stuff, and an encouragement to us. I recommend “You Can Change” by Tim Chester. Our small group leaders are currently going through this with our pastoral team. The ‘gap’ between our desire to change in order to become more like Christ, and the wisdom to change, is often confusing, troubling, and frustrating too.

    Your post and your message provide some of that much needed wisdom and grace.


  5. Timothy Tinnirello March 18, 2015 at 10:55 am

    Doing some writing, and I really believe it is inspired by God, and I was looking for the very thing you wrote yesterday in this article. Always amazes how God listens, and responds.

    Thanks for your work.

  6. Thanks for this encouragement to look to Christ — I appreciated your exhortation here.

  7. For me, suffering includes the added compone t of trust. “For now we see inpart”. Do I trust the Lord is divine, in control and can do all things? It reminds me of a child, clinging to his mothers hand as he walks into the doctors office for his vaccinations, totally scared, totally clinging to mom, totally hoping to avoid the suffering, yet totally trusting Mom. That is the place suffering brings me to, clinging to God, drawing near to God, hiding under the shadow of his wing, knowing He’s got good somewhere in this mess.

  8. “He does the same with us, though (as Paul reminds us) our battle isn’t against flesh and blood, but against spiritual powers.” And so was their battle also. Not against flesh and blood but against spiritual powers.

  9. That was truly helpful. You the best JD

  10. Just had a guest teacher come teach on Romans 7 at our church this weekend. He believes that the “correct ” interpretation for this is that it was pre-conversion Paul. I was a bit stunned as I had not heard that interpretation for a long time now. That evening I tried to convince myself, “Well, the meat of the message was true. I don’t have to get hung up on the point about whether this is ‘pre-conversion or post conversion.’” Well, the next morning I woke up and thought, “Hmmm what did I hear Pastor J.D. say at the ERLC Conference last year about John Newton?” Then I found this post by you. It DOES matter where you stand on Romans 7, and yes, the sin I see daily draws me to the cross to receive continuous grace and mercy in time of need.

Trackbacks and Pingbacks:

  1. March 16, 2015 Truth2Freedom Daily Blogroll Collection | Truth2Freedom's Blog - March 17, 2015

    [...] Read more [...]

  2. Why God Doesn’t Remove Our Sin - ajerda.com - March 17, 2015

    [...] via Why God Doesn’t Remove Our Sinful Cravings Immediately | J.D. GREEAR. [...]

  3. 3-18-15 Interesting Finds | joel hollins - March 18, 2015

    [...] Why God doesn’t remove our sinful cravings immediately – JD Geear [...]

  4. March 18, 2015 Truth2Freedom Daily Blogroll Collection | Truth2Freedom's Blog - March 18, 2015

    [...] Read more [...]

  5. Credo Magazine » Credo’s Cache - March 20, 2015

    [...] Why God Doesn’t Remove Our Sinful Cravings Immediately: By J.D. Greear - Greear says: “So when you are tempted to despair because you continue to [...]

  6. Sanctified Time Pass 23/03/15 | Marg Families - March 23, 2015

    [...] Why God Doesn’t Remove our Sinful Cravings This is a great question and one that I have struggled to answer and come to terms with. Maybe you are there also, have a look. [...]

  7. 24 Great Links for Leaders, Readers, and Creatives - March 27, 2015 - May 8, 2015

    [...] Why God Doesn’t Remove Our Sinful Cravings Immediately, by J. D. Greear [...]

Leave a Reply


Text formatting is available via select HTML. <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>